Board Thread:General Grimm Discussion/@comment-26144319-20151102024103

This is something that I'm still questioning and wondering myself. Is Diana...in any way possible....a villain? I know Diana's been mostly with Kelly Burkhardt and Meisner, but that doesn't fully mean she can't be evil.

I know you'll all doubt me, but can we think about this?

Here's some thoughts I have that I don't think Diana will be her little brother's protector and instead someone to use.

1. Anger with mom over her brother. Diana has no idea she has a younger half-brother with another man, and likely will be pissed when she finds out. I say this because I think she'll believe that her mom cheated on some man because she wanted to start her life over. I know she was at the house and Nick didn't like her mother, but she was only a baby when it was occuring and she was mostly out of arguments, and life was going sloppy with her mom. I know she was with Nick's mom, but that doesn't really mean anything. Also, Kelly was never aware that Diana's mother was carrying KB, so that cause even more of a flame. Finally, since she's 3/4 Hexenbiest, her emotions could control her, and would automatically hate KB. Sure, last reason's sloppy, but I'm trying to put my best reasons why I don't trust her. Anyway, when she does find out, she could probably hurt Kelly, use her magic to turn him into someone he's not, or kill him. This would damage Nick, and could possibly lead to him killing Adalind, Diana and Renard all at once. Also while she likes Meisner and Kelly because one helped her get delivered and the other raised her before she started becoming a child, she never shows this likeness anywhere else and is mostly neutral, implying that her trust on people is limited depending on how they act. Sure, she didn't cry when her mother was holding her, but she didn't really question much on where or how Adalind was.

2. She could manipulate him into thinking that if he joined her side, she could save Portland. First off, like my last reason for the first paragraph, she's 3/4 Hexenbiest, and Hexenbiests at times can maniuplate others or be manipulated into doing a certain action. It's likely she could decieve her brother in hatred to make specific actions only to turn him against his family. Secondly, since she was shown to use powers like float up objects or various other abilities, she could mind control him into giving her ultimate power, and use illusion for certain parts to do so. Third, she has done this before, as she made Meisner pick up firewood because she made the illusion that the firewood was actually her, and Juliette before she became a Hexenbiest, once picked up Diana, only to find out she picked up a pillow. Decieving is her key power.

3. There are 1 or 2 things that question of whether or not she's good, and (coressponding a little to one statement of reason 1) she won't help with her brother very much. To start, when she was with her grandfather in Season 4, she knocked the castle down and rebuilt it into a much larger one. Now you're all saying, "Okay, so what's the problem with that?", well, she's a princess due to her being a member of the royals, and because she doesn't know what the real world has due to being shunted from the public and Royals, and because she still isn't raised the right way, she is likely to believe that she can be who she wants. I know Meisner is with the resistance and has her, but she doesn't fully know how life works and what is going on. Another, she didn't have any response to Kelly being attacked or murdered, and didn't help. I know it's not her job to fight the royals, and she's only a kid, but she heard Kelly be attacked, and saw the blood on Kenneth's face,and didn't care, she just sat there, and when the royals had her, she just questioned where her mom was, unworried. Also, since she's older than Kelly, it's likely if she ever deals with him, she'll mostly insult him, or fight him, or just embaress him. I know while there's parts where siblings defend each other when it comes to bullies, but about 99% of the time, it's mostly the old brother defending his little sister. Take for example, The Poor Kid, one of the season finales of South Park, Karen is cornered by a bully, who wants the doll, but Mysterion defends Karen, beats up the bully, and takes Karen back to her classroom. Sure, there are movies such as Air Buddies where the younger sibling defends the older ones, but how common is it for the older sister to defend her little brother? Unless someone can give me a film that was critically successful, I'd say .00001%. I'm sorry, but in the films I've ever seen, the Older sister never defends her brother, nor looks up to his older sister as a hero. (And no, Finding Nemo doesn't count because Dory and Nemo aren't related.) Look, I shouldn't judge by age, but it's very common for an older sister to not help her brother.

Okay, if anyone points out flaws, I'll try to rewatch the episodes to strengthen my points, but that doesn't remove the theory that Diana is bad. Being raised by good people as a baby right now doesn't mean anything. Anyway, if you're angry of what I think, you can rant here, but please read my points first. 