Board Thread:Comic, Novel & Other Discussion/@comment-24173809-20131231010321/@comment-4672536-20131231211255

For me, it's got to be Jinnamuru Xunte. That was the very few times I was crepped out by the show (and I am able to get through the gory body parts, but not eaten out eyes with worms somehow).

However, the creepiest overall paranormal creature in the show has got to be La Llorona. Just thinking about her makes me incredibly frightened.

Then again, Krampus is a close second (I don't really think he is a Wesen).